If you’ve spent time in fan spaces for The Summer I Turned Pretty, you’ve likely seen the same question again and again: Is Jeremiah Fisher LGBTQ? The character’s easy charm and offhand comments have fueled plenty of speculation. This article separates what the show actually establishes from what fans theorize, and looks at how the TV series deliberately rewrote Jeremiah’s story from the original books.
Character portrayed by: Gavin Casalegno · Series appearance: The Summer I Turned Pretty (Prime Video) · First season: 2022 · IMDb rating (series): 7.3/10 (based on 37,000+ votes) · Character role: Main character, love interest, middle Fisher brother
Quick snapshot
- Jeremiah is a fictional character from The Summer I Turned Pretty (IMDb (series page))
- Portrayed by actor Gavin Casalegno (Elite Daily (entertainment outlet))
- In the books, Belly marries Conrad, not Jeremiah (TODAY (news network))
- Whether the TV series will deviate from the book ending for Belly’s love choice (PinkNews (LGBTQ+ media outlet))
- Whether the character has an explicit LGBTQ label in official canon (no statement from showrunners) (Them (LGBTQ+ culture publication))
- Season 1 (2022) introduced Jeremiah’s same-sex kiss (Them)
- Season 3 synopsis indicates Belly is with Jeremiah at the start (PinkNews)
- Season 3 expected to adapt final book We’ll Always Have Summer (ET (entertainment news))
- Possible resolution of the love triangle (TODAY) (ET (entertainment news))
Here is a quick reference to key facts about Jeremiah Fisher.
| Label | Value |
|---|---|
| Actor full name | Gavin Perry Casalegno |
| Actor age (as of 2025) | 25 |
| Character debut | 2022 (Season 1, Episode 1) |
| Character age (approx.) | 16–18 in series |
| Known for | Middle sibling, basketball player, humorous demeanor |
Is Jeremiah Fisher LGBTQ?
Canon indications from the show
- Author Jenny Han described Jeremiah as an “equal opportunity flirt” and “sexually fluid” (Elite Daily)
- In Season 1, Jeremiah kisses a male character, establishing on-screen queer behavior (Them)
- When accused of being a “queer baiter,” Jeremiah responds, “I’m just equal opportunity” (Them)
The show deliberately re-coded Jeremiah as sexually fluid, a meaningful shift from the books where he was written as straight. But the portrayal has drawn criticism for feeding the “bisexual cheater” trope, as noted by Them.
Does Jeremiah Fisher kiss a boy?
Yes, in Season 1 Jeremiah shares a same-sex kiss with a male character, which is the most explicit on-screen queer behavior in the series (Them).
Fan interpretations and debate
- Fans often label Jeremiah as bisexual in online discussions, though the show never uses the label (Them)
- Some critics argue the bisexual coding is underused in later episodes (Them)
- No official canon confirmation from the showrunners exists (Elite Daily)
The implication: The show treats Jeremiah as queer in action but avoids a fixed label, leaving room for audience interpretation — and sparking both praise and concern about representation.
Who is Jeremiah Fisher?
Role in ‘The Summer I Turned Pretty’
- Middle Fisher brother, son of Susannah and Cleveland Fisher (IMDb character database)
- Portrayed by Gavin Casalegno, an American actor born September 2, 1999 (Elite Daily)
- Known for his charm, basketball skills, and a jealous streak toward his brother Conrad (TODAY)
What is Jeremiah Fisher’s name in real life?
The character is portrayed by actor Gavin Perry Casalegno, born September 2, 1999, who also appears in other projects such as When the Game Stands Tall (Elite Daily).
Is Jeremiah Fisher married in real life?
Gavin Casalegno, the actor who portrays Jeremiah, is not publicly reported as married.
Character personality and arc
- Jeremiah is initially portrayed as the fun, outgoing brother who uses humor to mask insecurity (ET)
- His relationship with Belly evolves from friendship to romance by the end of Season 2 (PinkNews)
- Some fans criticize his possessiveness over Belly, while others root for his emotional openness (Them)
The pattern: Jeremiah is a layered character — sweet and funny on the surface, but driven by a deep need for validation that complicates his relationships.
Jeremiah Fisher vs Conrad: Who does Belly end up with?
Two brothers, one choice. Here’s how the characters compare across key dimensions.
| Aspect | Jeremiah Fisher | Conrad Fisher |
|---|---|---|
| Role in love triangle | Belly’s official boyfriend by end of S2 | Belly’s first love, ex-boyfriend |
| Book outcome | Belly eventually marries Conrad | Wins Belly’s heart in the series finale |
| TV series trajectory | Romance with Belly is central to S2–S3 | Returns in S3, causing conflict |
| Personality | Outgoing, flirtatious, insecure | Brooding, intellectual, guarded |
| Fan archetype | “Golden retriever” energy | “Brooding bad boy” |
Book vs series canon
- In Jenny Han’s book trilogy, Belly marries Conrad (TODAY)
- The TV series has not concluded; Season 3 is expected to adapt the final book We’ll Always Have Summer (ET)
- Author Jenny Han has hinted the show may diverge from the books (Elite Daily)
Fan allegiances and author statements
- Fan camps are split between Team Jeremiah and Team Conrad, with strong opinions on both sides (PinkNews)
- Jenny Han has said she is open to changing the ending for the adaptation (TODAY)
Choosing Jeremiah over Conrad would be a major departure from the source material, but it would also reward viewers who have invested in Jeremiah’s arc. The showrunners face the challenge of satisfying both book loyalists and TV-original fans.
The catch: The series has built up Jeremiah and Belly’s relationship so strongly that a Conrad ending in Season 3 could feel like a retcon, yet the books’ legacy pulls in the opposite direction.
Clarity check
Confirmed facts
- Jeremiah Fisher is a fictional character from The Summer I Turned Pretty (IMDb series page)
- Portrayed by actor Gavin Casalegno (Elite Daily)
- In the books, Belly marries Conrad, not Jeremiah (TODAY)
- Season 1 includes a same-sex kiss for Jeremiah (Them)
What’s unclear
- Whether the TV series will deviate from the book ending for Belly’s love choice (PinkNews)
- Whether the character has an explicit LGBTQ label in official canon (Them)
- How the bisexual coding will be developed in Season 3 (Them)
This clarity check separates what is confirmed from what remains unknown about Jeremiah’s character and the series’ direction.
Perspectives from the cast and creator
“He’s an equal opportunity flirt. He’s sexually fluid, and he’s a young person figuring out where he falls.”
— Jenny Han, author of The Summer I Turned Pretty, to Elite Daily
“I’m just equal opportunity.”
— Jeremiah Fisher (as written in the show), quoted in Them
“Jeremiah and Belly’s relationship is real and complicated. He loves her, but he’s also scared of losing her.”
— Gavin Casalegno, actor, in an interview with ET
The debate around Jeremiah Fisher isn’t just about a fictional character — it reflects a larger conversation about how bisexual representation is handled in mainstream teen dramas. For fans waiting for Season 3, the question of Belly’s final choice is still open, but the show has already made its position on Jeremiah’s sexuality clear: he is not straight, and that’s not a punchline. For viewers who want honest, fluid queer representation, the series has taken a step forward — even if it still has room to grow.
tiktok.com, thepinknews.com, reddit.com, youtube.com, decider.com, thesummeriturnedpretty.fandom.com, thesummeriturnedpretty.fandom.com, betches.com
For a deeper breakdown of the actor’s biography and the ongoing speculation, check out Jeremiah Fishers actor and LGBTQ status for more verified details.
Frequently asked questions
Who is Jeremiah Fisher in ‘The Summer I Turned Pretty’?
He is the middle Fisher brother, a main character and love interest of Belly Conklin, portrayed by Gavin Casalegno.
Is Jeremiah Fisher based on a real person?
No, he is a fictional character created by author Jenny Han for her book series.
What is Gavin Casalegno’s real age?
He was born September 2, 1999, making him 25 as of 2025.
Does Jeremiah Fisher have any special talents in the show?
He is portrayed as a skilled basketball player and a charismatic, easygoing friend.
Why is Jeremiah Fisher a controversial character?
Some fans criticize his jealous behavior and the way his bisexuality is handled, while others praise his emotional depth and comic relief.
Where can I watch ‘The Summer I Turned Pretty’?
All available seasons are streaming on Prime Video.
The above answers address the most common questions about Jeremiah Fisher and the actor who plays him.
Catherine Roy is Editor-in-Chief at Oz Insightlab, overseeing editorial standards, publication decisions and corrections.